Pro­se­mi­nar: Sys­tem Se­cu­ri­ty SS24

The topic of this years' Proseminar is “Systemization of Knowledge” (SoK). An SoK paper evaluates, systematizes, and contextualizes existing knowledge in an established, major research area. The goal of a SoK paper is to benefit readers by surveying, summarizing, and bringing conceptual order to the large body of accumulated knowledge in the field.

In this seminar students work in pairs (groups of two people) on one topic. The aim of the SoK paper in this seminar is to

  • introduce the technical aspects of the topic and
  • give an overview of various attacks using the technology, vulnerabilities of the technology, or privacy issues with the technology.

The seminar presentations (mandatory attendance) are expected to take place as a block seminar at the end of the lecture period.

About this Seminar

In our seminar, you should learn to present research results in a concise manner, both in writing (Seminar Thesis) and speaking (Seminar Presentation). Additionally, you should learn to give proper feedback, for both the presentation and the thesis of other students in this seminar.

To achieve these goals, we have the following main parts in our seminar (in chronological order):

  1. Submission of a preliminary version of the seminar paper.
    This submission is intended to provide a very early feedback on your paper.
  2. Submission of a pre-final version of the seminar paper.
    This is a finished version of your seminar paper that is then reviewed by other students in the seminar.
  3. Submission of the reviews.
    Each student is assigned and has to submit two reviews of their peers papers. The reviews you receive should help you to improve your own paper.
  4. Presentation of your paper.
    This presentation is held in front of the whole seminar, and you grade each other, the presentation that receives the highest grade from their peers receives the “Best Presentation” award. (This grade is independent of the grade you receive from us for the presentation.)
  5. Submission of the final version of the seminar paper.
    This version includes the feedback from the reviews and is the one graded by us.

Additionally, we have presentations on the topics of research, writing, review, and presentation skills.


There are two topic complexes (Network Security and Document Security). Each group chooses one topic (with no conflic to other groups). If you have an idea for a topic in either of the categories below that you are interested in you may contact us and ask if you can do you own topic.


  • IPv6
  • Denial of Service
  • DHCP
  • DNS
  • BGP
  • IoT Protocols

Document Security:

  • Word/LibreOffice/...
  • PDF


  • The topics are distributed in the first week of the semester.
  • The presentations of the seminar papers will be held as a block seminar at the end of the semester.
    • The date is 15.7. 13:00 - 17:00


  • 17.5.: Partial Seminar Paper Submission
  • 24.6.: Final Seminar Paper Submission
  • 8.7.: Peer Review Submission
  • 14.7.: Presentation Slide Submission (you can still change your slides a bit before the talk)
  • 21.7.: Camera-Ready Seminar Paper Submission

The seminar will be organized over Panda. Deadlines are till the end of the day (23:59 local time/as according to Panda).


We will have five meetings, with different topics which will (hopefully) be helpful for you to pass the seminar:

  • 11.4. 9:15 in FU.207 Introduction
  • Online Research Skills
  • Online Writing Skills
  • Online Review Skills
  • Online Presentation Skills

Grading, Demands, and Expectations

The final grade consists of your presentation (30%), your paper (60%), and your reviews (10%). Additionally, you must meet all deadlines. Getting 0% (i.e. not submitting/not presenting) means failing the seminar.

For students from different majors (like CE) that get 3 (instead of 4) ECTS for this course the review is omitted and the paper counts as 70%.

Seminar Paper

Preliminary Version

  • at least 5 pages of text (excluding title page, table of contents, references, figures, …)
  • describes the main paper problem
  • briefly describe 5 related papers citing your paper

Final Version

  • Essay written according to the standards of a scientific paper.
    Unless otherwise discussed with us:
    • Your paper should summarize the original paper.
    • You should introduce concepts so that any other student in the seminar can understand your paper. (This does not include basic cryptographic/computer science terms.)
    • Like the preliminary, the final paper version has to describe two papers that cite the original. This should give a broader context for your paper.
  • It MUST be written using our LaTeX template (unchanged).
  • We expect around 15 pages of content, the hard lower limit is 9 pages of text (excluding title page, table of contents, references, figures, …). In most cases, the paper should not be longer than 20 pages of content.


  • 20 minutes presentation. 5 minutes discussion and questions.

The best presentation will be awarded! More information will be given in the first meeting.


We will follow a peer review procedure similar to scientific publications:

  • You submit your paper on PANDA
  • Some (2) peers (other students) review your submission:
    • Read and understand the submitted paper
    • Criticize your paper
    • Make recommendations on how to improve
    • Be honest, polite, and helpful when writing your reviews
  • The reviews you receive will not influence your final grade (but you should address/apply them in your final version)
  • Each student has to write 1 review (1–2 pages)